Tuesday, 27 April 2010

The Best Whoopie Pie Recipe



This is not my first attempt at whoopie pies but this recipe is by far the best I have tried.  I am really really pleased with it.  I found this recipe at the fabulous Donal' blog Good Mood Food , the whoopies in his pictures have perfectly smooth tops which is exactly what I was after.  The last recipe I tried resulted in cracked tops like a chocolate cupcake and I wasn't happy.  The only problem I could foresee with this recipe was that Donal's whoopies looked a little flat so I added just a smidgen extra baking powder.  My whoopies therefore did puff up just a little more, yay!

The filling is good but not Buttercream Bakery good, so next time I think I will use my own recipe.  The peanut butter frosting from my last whoopie pie post was, in my opinion much better.




I piped my whoopies as usual, Donal's spoon method seems a bit of a palaver.  I decided to do two different sizes big cookie size and small cookie size, I topped my smaller whoopies with milk chocolate ganache.



Scrumptious!

Chocolate Whoopie Pies
.
Makes 16 whoopie pies

120g butter
190g sugar
2 eggs
270g of flour
5 tablespoons of good quality cocoa powder
1 teaspoon of baking powder
1/2 teaspoon of salt
1 teaspoon of vanilla extract
250ml of buttermilk

Filling:

250g icing sugar
170g butter
2 egg whites
1 teaspoon of vanilla extract
A pinch of salt



Preheat the oven to 180°C/Gas Mark 4 and line two baking sheets.

Combine the flour, cocoa powder, baking powder and salt in a bowl.

In another bowl, using an electric whisk, cream the sugar and the butter until pale and fluffy. Add in the egg, mixing again to combine.

Slowly add the buttermilk and vanilla extract and dry ingredients to the bowl, in batches, mixing until everything is combined and you are left with a thick batter.

Spoon (or pipe) rounded teaspoons of the batter onto lined baking sheets, allowing space for them to spread while cooking. Place in the oven for approximately 15 minutes or until the tops have puffed up and spring back when lightly pressed.

While the mini pies halves are baking, prepare the filling by beating together all the ingredients until you are left with a nice smooth mix.

When they are cooked, remove the mini pie halves from the baking sheets with a metal spatula and place on wire rack to cool.

When the mini pies halves have cooled, spread a rounded teaspoon of the creamy filling on the flat side and sandwich together with another.




I highly recommend this recipe, I halved it with no problems at all and the whoopies were deliciously moist and chocolaty.  This is definitely going to be my go to whoopie pie recipe from now on and I would like to send a huge thank you to the lovely Mrs Linda Daunt for sending her mother in laws fantastic recipe to The Good Mood Food Blog, these truly are scrumptious and I am so pleased I found I found it.






Share/Bookmark

12 comments:

Paris Pastry said...

I should really get into making whoopie pies. I don't think I've ever made them myself!

HoosierHomemade said...

Those look amazing! Thanks for sharing the recipe!
-Liz

How To Be Perfect said...

Paris Pastry your flutternutter frosting would be amazing in these whoopies!!!!

Brownieville Girl said...

All I can say is yummm!!!

Lavinia said...

Hello from Romania! Your receipe was great! I made 22 delicious woopie. I will repeat soon. Thank you verry much!
All the best!!!
Lavinia

Anonymous said...

hi :) your whoopies looks amazing and tasty.. i will try they tomorow at my restaurant :)
greetings from Norway :)

Anonymous said...

I'm having a problem :( I'm currently beating all the ingredients together for the filling and its just looking like some pale watery mess :( any idea what could be wrong?

Astral de la Mare said...

Hi Anon,

It sounds like the mixture may not have been beaten fully. You could try adding a little extra icing sugar to thicken the consistency but from your description I don't think that is the problem.

It could also be that your butter was not room temperature before you combined the ingredients. This would result in the butter forming little lumps and not combining with the remaining ingredients.

I hope that helps!

DaniUndead said...

Is this posted recipe with the original-but-not-as-great filling?

Astral de la Mare said...

Hi DaniUndead,

Yes this recipe has been posted with the original frosting recipe, it wasn't bad, just not fantastic.
If you're looking for another frosting recipe have a peek at the cake and cupcakes section of my recipe index. I include a frosting recipe in almost everyone.

These would be amazing with caramel or salted caramel buttercream. x

daphne said...

Hi

Thanks for sharing this recipe.

I tried this recipe yesterday. The whoopie pies came out pretty flat.
Are they supposed to be flat or "dome-shapes"?

Astral de la Mare said...

Hi Daphne,

No these whoopie pies are not particularly domed. I manage to get the smallest of domes on mine but the origional recipe shows completely flat whoopie pies.

I've tried many more domed whoopie recipes since then but I still think this is one of the yummiest, dome or no dome.